Recent Posts
Recent Comments
Most Commented On
Archives
Blog
Link This | Email this | Blog This | Comments (48)
Tattooed Librarians are DiverseAugust 3, 2009 A kind read sent this on wondering what my response would be. It's easy enough to report my initial response: Yuck! Apparently I'm the last person in the country who finds extensive and very visible tattooing indecorous to the point of repulsion, and I'm not impressed by a tattooed librarian. And the only thing less impressive than a tattooed librarian is an entire calendar full of them. Go ahead, call me a prude. It wouldn't be the worst thing you've ever called me.I have to admit I was mesmerized by the web page, though. Surprise and disgust turned into bafflement and disbelief. There just seems to be so much wrong with this entire idea. I'm working under the assumption that in addition to raising money, the calendar also aims to dispel librarian stereotypes. It doesn't say this outright, but it does seem to be one intention. That in itself is enough to annoy me. What's so bad about librarian stereotypes? In some cases it's absolutely true. When I remove my glasses and shake the bun from my hair, I am a sex goddess, and a tattoo would only ruin the effect. How many professions attract sexual fetishists, after all. It's not like people conjure up images of engineers and say, "when he removed those coke-bottle glasses and that pocket protector, he was like a god!" But back to the calendar. Let's begin with the title: "The Tattooed Ladies of TLA." Why are there no tattooed men of TLA? There must be some male librarians down in Texas, and it being Texas and all surely plenty of them have tattoos. And why is it "ladies" instead of "women"? I hate that. Maybe they want to associate themselves with painted ladies (the houses, not the hussies), but then they'd need some librarians as big as houses. Those shouldn't be too hard to find. The advertisement says, "Libraries thrive on and promote diversity and freedom of expression. The Tattooed Ladies ofTLA calendar is a testament to both." Uh huh. Having no men and calling the librarians "ladies" seems to me to promote sexist stereotypes more than diversity. But that's just me. It's that "promoting diversity" baloney that makes me think this is one of those attempts to fight librarian stereotypes. These librarians aren't prim and proper! They won't shush you! They're diverse! This isn't just a big group of mostly white women. This is a big group of mostly white women with tattoos! However, they are fighting the stereotype of diversity propaganda. When institutions want to promote how diverse they are, they usually have pictures with at least some token African-American representation. University publicity sites love to have photos showing the harmony of ebony and ivory on their campuses. The closest this page comes is one Latina. Stereotypical diversity propaganda shows many people of many colors, but the tattooed ladies calendar dispels that stereotype by proclaiming how diverse a bunch of white, female librarians are. They're certainly not fighting the stereotype of librarians as behind the times, though. I mean, seriously, a print calendar? Who uses those things anymore? They say "forget those predictable calendars with cute puppies and nature photographs," but who would buy print calendars with cute puppies on them anyway? If the answer is librarians, I don't want to know, because it would only depress me. This is a fundraiser for the TLA Library Disaster Relief Fund, and I'm sure they need the money. Maybe librarians who look like biker chicks are a hot commodity down in Texas, and they know their audience. Obviously I'm out of their demographic, though, because I'd gladly pay $20 not to have to look at any tattooed librarians. Fortunately, I can usually do that for free. Posted by Annoyed Librarian on August 3, 2009 | Comments (48) Industries: Opinion
August 3, 2009
In response to: Tattooed Librarians are Diverse LibraryStudent commented: I also would pay $20 not to have to see that calendar. I like the stereotype (uptight book guardian/coquettish sex goddess) and sometimes think that's part of the attraction to the profession. But that's just it -- a profession. I'm curious to know how this publication will affect the professionalism of those librarians who choose to be in it. I know I might have a hard time shaking a slightly disturbing image of one of these slightly portly inked-women as they attempt to develop a fan base similar to that of the Suicide Girls out of my head when I go to their library in search of a book or other information. While at first glance it sounds like a fun idea, on the whole it could be more damaging than not.
August 3, 2009
In response to: Tattooed Librarians are Diverse Jane commented: Is this Laura Bush's idea? I suspected she might step out and cause some trouble once GW got out of the White House.
August 3, 2009
In response to: Tattooed Librarians are Diverse poking holes in your theory commented: "How many professions attract sexual fetishists, after all."
August 3, 2009
In response to: Tattooed Librarians are Diverse Midge commented: The webpage looks like a bad porn site and the calendar layout doesn't seem to help. Could they not have made it look a little more professional?
August 3, 2009
In response to: Tattooed Librarians are Diverse AL=RK commented: Was it something we said?
August 3, 2009
In response to: Tattooed Librarians are Diverse Whiner commented: I'm sorry ... just not all that attractive. With or without the tattoos, but especially <i>with</i>.
August 3, 2009
In response to: Tattooed Librarians are Diverse anonymous commented: "And why is it "ladies" instead of "women"? I hate that."
August 3, 2009
In response to: Tattooed Librarians are Diverse Up and coming librarian commented: I think this is one of the most creative and just plain cool ideas ever. I love the irony.
August 3, 2009
In response to: Tattooed Librarians are Diverse Library Lady commented: I like it when librarians buck the stereotype. I hate it whenever someone tells me, "You don't look like a librarian" because I don't know if I should take it as a personal compliment or professional insult. I say as long as these women aren't wearing cat themed sweaters and have helmety-hobbit-like hairdos then let them get their library freak on and have their admirerers buy the silly calendar.
August 3, 2009
In response to: Tattooed Librarians are Diverse Turgid commented: Oh yuck, that's grotesque!
August 3, 2009
In response to: Tattooed Librarians are Diverse anonymous commented: I like highly visible, unconcealable tattoos. It helps me determine who has poor impulse control and trouble planning for the future.
August 3, 2009
In response to: Tattooed Librarians are Diverse Mr. Tadakichi commented: "...a print calendar? Who uses those things anymore?"
August 4, 2009
In response to: Tattooed Librarians are Diverse dork commented: Oooh, Gretchen! But what's up with that purple feathery bikini?
August 4, 2009
In response to: Tattooed Librarians are Diverse Captain Spaulding commented: My life was wrapped around the circus.
August 4, 2009
In response to: Tattooed Librarians are Diverse anonymous commented: I am a non-tattooed Texas librarian who also does not appreciate the calendar. They were looking for a fun way to raise money for a good cause. I really was rather put off by the entire idea when I first heard about it, and am a little disgusted by the resulting calendar. I also did not purchase the previous calendar -- "Men of Texas Libraries" advertised as "a celebration of the humor and complexity of that precious natural resource – men in library land." It gets hot here in Texas. I just think the 100+ degree heat has fried some brains. Or else some really smart people just got bored and wanted to have some fun. Got to admit it, though -- it got some attention.
August 4, 2009
In response to: Tattooed Librarians are Diverse ChickenLittle commented: The Latina chick librarian in the top middle row is HOT!! With or without the tattoo! Any straight male librarian would be lucky to have her around! The rest all look pretty standard!
August 4, 2009
In response to: Tattooed Librarians are Diverse LS commented: "Why are there no tattooed men of TLA?"
August 4, 2009
In response to: Tattooed Librarians are Diverse NiYut commented: I'm a tattooed librarian in Nebraska and I hate the calendar.
August 4, 2009
In response to: Tattooed Librarians are Diverse MT commented: Librarians Librarians...lets be nice. Now I am not your stereo typical librarian myself and yea I have a tattoo. Do I show my tattoo off? No but if someone told me hey we have an idea, if you show us your tattoo and let us take a picture we might be able to save another librarian's job, get funding that we lost from budget cuts or heck give some well deserving clerks a raise. Id do it in a heart beat and dare someone to challenge my professionalism. My Gosh if you look most of the ladies have tattoos that can be covered. I am inspired by the fact these women had the courage to do this.
August 4, 2009
In response to: Tattooed Librarians are Diverse Who cares? commented: No one outside the library profession follows any of this stuff. Bucking stereotypes or not, it doesn't matter because librarians are the only ones who will notice or care.
August 4, 2009
In response to: Tattooed Librarians are Diverse Coppertop commented: I'm thinking that one of those females looks like she could have been on last year's men of Texas calendar. Cheap shot I know.
August 4, 2009
In response to: Tattooed Librarians are Diverse end stereotypes commented: Anything to end the stereotype of librarians. Please. Good for them for fundraising!
August 4, 2009
In response to: Tattooed Librarians are Diverse KT commented: Were there no real news stories to comment on today?
August 4, 2009
In response to: Tattooed Librarians are Diverse JR commented: Lighten up:) Any idea that can help the library is wonderful!
August 4, 2009
In response to: Tattooed Librarians are Diverse AL commented: Yes, there were no real news stories to comment on today. That's why you're spending time commenting on this blog. Thanks for reading!
August 4, 2009
In response to: Tattooed Librarians are Diverse anonymous commented: The real news is Library Journal is up for sale, and who knows, perhaps the AL will have to get a tatoo to help sweeten the deal. I wonder if AL read all the fine print in her contract?
August 4, 2009
In response to: Tattooed Librarians are Diverse Seriously? commented: You're a librarian...how about freedom of expression? I can't believe how many of you are hating on them and tattoos. Do you really think this does anything to the image of librarians? Grow up and stop bashing people for wanting express themselves and raise a little money for a good cause.
August 4, 2009
In response to: Tattooed Librarians are Diverse tattoed husband/wife librarian couple in commented: "...in addition to raising money, the calendar also aims to dispel librarian stereotypes. It doesn't say this outright, but it does seem to be one intention."
August 5, 2009
In response to: Tattooed Librarians are Diverse f8hrn commented: Just a pet peeve, but you can't hate On someone. You can hate someone but not on them. Well, I guess you could but it would be weird.
August 5, 2009
In response to: Tattooed Librarians are Diverse f8hrn commented: Which reminds me -- I was taking a tour of my daughter's high school last night (she's in 9th grade) which supposedly stresses academics and the honor student giving the tour used the word whatever in every sentence. Oh well, whatever.
August 5, 2009
In response to: Tattooed Librarians are Diverse TruTexan commented: I'm the one who brought this item to AL's attention (I'm assuming...there may have been someone before me).
August 5, 2009
In response to: Tattooed Librarians are Diverse TruTexan commented: I'm the one who brought this item to AL's attention (I'm assuming...there may have been someone before me).
August 5, 2009
In response to: Tattooed Librarians are Diverse AngelaB commented: This is stupid. I have a tattoo, but I don't feel the need to show it off. Personally, I prefer to keep things professional at my job. I don't need to look "cool" or "hip." I think it is degrading that some librarians think they have to be. It's just a job.
August 5, 2009
In response to: Tattooed Librarians are Diverse KT commented: You're welcome! And for the record, I read lots of library blogs and rarely comment, but when a corporate librarian eviscerates a public library's fundraising efforts I find the need to comment.
August 5, 2009
In response to: Tattooed Librarians are Diverse JR commented: I would like to thank tattooed husband/wife librarian couple who mentioned the inappropriate comments about the women's appearance.
August 5, 2009
In response to: Tattooed Librarians are Diverse pi commented: Texas is the reason....
August 5, 2009
In response to: Tattooed Librarians are Diverse anonymous commented: I am a tattooed male librarian from Texas. I perhaps entered the profession to be close to the object of some (latent) librarian fetish, or perhaps not. I can say without doubt, however, that any inherent sexiness female librarians seem to hold for me took a great blow reading these comments. About the odd bikini, the "plump" figures, the "unprofessionalism"--ugh. Nothing is less attractive than this sort of uptight, rigid joylessness. Give me a fat closet biker librarian who knows how to smile any day.
August 6, 2009
In response to: Tattooed Librarians are Diverse jane commented: <i>The Latina chick librarian in the top middle row is HOT!!</i>--Agreed. She is stunning.
August 6, 2009
In response to: Tattooed Librarians are Diverse anonymous commented: What about the librarians who are tired of getting hit on by patrons at the desk? Might this calendar just reinforce that type of patron behavior?
August 6, 2009
In response to: Tattooed Librarians are Diverse get a life commented: "egregious unprofessionalism"?? It's not like they made a porno. Wow, you are uptight.
August 6, 2009
In response to: Tattooed Librarians are Diverse TwoQatz commented: Jane, we've got the opposite problem in my library. The men are the stodgiest and most humorless among our group. They can suck the joy out just about everything. That one of our youngest is so "rule-bound" and uptight amazes me. Youth can be so wasted on the young.
August 10, 2009
In response to: Tattooed Librarians are Diverse Ms. June 2010 commented: Hello DL - I'm the creative genius behind the Tattooed Ladies of TLA - and yes it was pure genius! Just spell our association's name right correctly when you make out your check in to support Disaster Relief. The title is alliterative and a homage to Groucho. So get a life DL and find a sense of humor!
August 10, 2009
In response to: Tattooed Librarians are Diverse Ms. June 2010 commented: Dear AL, Please forgive my use of the initialism DL without explanation in my previous post. I always think of you as DL - That "Dear Librarian" rather than merely the Annoying Librarian! You've frequently brought joy into my humdrum life, so remember Dear Librarian your postings haven't been in vain for nothing! And in this instance you've generated great interest in our Disaster Relief fundraiser and the Calendars are flying off the shelves. Just go to TLA website to place your own order and I would be happy autograph June 2010 and raise my martini glass in your honor. Our operators are standing by!
August 13, 2009
In response to: Tattooed Librarians are Diverse SideLined commented: In response to "anonymous commented: I like highly visible, unconcealable tattoos. It helps me determine who has poor impulse control and trouble planning for the future", I just have to say that is one of the best one-liners I've heard in a while.
August 13, 2009
In response to: Tattooed Librarians are Diverse Techserving You commented: I guess the comment I posted when this blog entry was first up was deleted. The thrust of my original comment, which I think was better-written the first time, was this: It seems that whenever librarians write about/act on changing the 'stereotype,' (or, for that matter, whenever some real news organization, such as the NY Times, reports on this) they simply replace one stereotype with another. (Yes, the NY Times actually wrote an article about 'hipster librarians.') It's the hipster/indie librarian stereotype which most people try to advance, and to me, this is just as annoying as the traditional stereotype. I have no interest in being some thriftshop-clothes-wearing, granny glasses (in a cool way)-wearing, tattooed indie 'hipster.' If anything, we should be trying to let people know that the 'profession' includes the same variety of people that any other field includes. (I think it does, just not with the same distribution of types... lets face it, the traditional stereotype exists because there is much truth to it.) I am in my early-thirties, have spent my whole adult life in major cities, think I'm pretty cool, and don't fit the traditional librarian stereotype. I'm pretty normal, not uptight and rules-obsessed, not obsessed with order although I work in tech. svs., etc.. I don't lean towards any extreme. I wear clothes from J.Crew, Banana Republic, L.L. Bean, as well as non-preppy stores. I'm just a normal person who happens to be a librarian. There are lots of us in this field, though we may not be as visible as some other types. Why do we want to trade one freaky stereotype for another? (No offense to people with tattoos... I'm going beyond this calendar now, since I see this new stereotype come up time and again.)
August 17, 2009
In response to: Tattooed Librarians are Diverse TLA Supporter commented: These ladies are just trying to raise some money. It seems that most of the people commenting on this blog are librarians, so they should understand the difficulty of this. Sometimes fund raising is a messy, wild affair. Publicity goes to those who break outside the mold, and nothing is more important to fund raising than publicity. Give the TLA a break for daring to think outside the box.
August 24, 2009
In response to: Tattooed Librarians are Diverse Sherryw commented: *sigh*
September 8, 2009
In response to: Tattooed Librarians are Diverse Jessica commented: Well, it's good to know that fat-hate, tat-hate, and general misogyny are acceptable in library land. Some of the comments here are pathetic. If I didn't love being a librarian, I'd take my fat, tattooed self to another profession - really, people, get a grip.
Advertisement
|
Advertisements
|
|
|
|