Library Journal Mobile
Log In  |  Register          Free Newsletter Subscription
Subscribe to LJ Magazine

Librarian's Book Choice Sparks Controversy at Ohio State's Mansfield Campus

-- Library Journal, 4/25/2006

Two faculty members filed charges of sexual harassment against a Ohio State University, Mansfield (OSUM) librarian, contending his defense of a controversial book they call hateful and homophobic created a hostile workplace environment. The charges have been withdrawn, but the tension lingers. Scott Savage head of reference and instructional services at OSUM's Bromfield library, suggested four books for the program, including David Kupelian's The Marketing of Evil, published by the right-wing WorldNet Daily (WND), where Kupelian is managing editor. In his email suggesting titles, which also included Rick Santorum's It Takes a Family and David Horowitz's The Professors, Savage admitted he hadn't read all the titles he suggested, but wanted to suggest titles that "confront the accepted wisdom" of the university. When faculty members objected to Kupelian's book, saying it lacked sufficient academic merit, Savage defended his choice, and over several email messages the matter escalated.

OSUM Bromfield Library director Beth Burns confirmed that Savage is considering a counterclaim against the university. The controversy, which OSUM dean and director Evie Freeman characterized in faculty meeting as a "colossal misunderstanding due to the use of email," has now taken on a life of its own in the press, thanks in part to press releases from the Alliance Defense Fund, which charged that universities are hostile to Christians and conservatives. Over a month ago, however, according to the faculty assembly's public minutes, one of the complainants, OSUM associate professor of English Norman Jones, told colleagues he had personally worked things out with Savage. Jones contends he was not against Savage's choice of conservative books, but that Kupelian's book simply did not meet sufficient standards of academic rigor. "I feel like [Savage] and I are more on the same page than I had realized," Jones said at a faculty meeting, according to the minutes. "His language called into question my academic credibility. It's clear that he deeply regrets his statements."

Talkback

We would love your feedback!

Post a comment

» VIEW ALL TALKBACK THREADS

Related Content

Related Content

 

By This Author

There are no other articles written by this author.

Sponsored Links




 
Advertisement
Sponsored Links

More Content

  • Blogs
  • Podcasts
  • Photos

Blogs

  • Cheryl LaGuardia
    E-Views

    July 3, 2009
    Another Bing Convert
    I’ve been playing with Bing (Microsoft’s new search service) ever since learning about i...
    More
  • Norman Oder
    In the Bookroom

    June 30, 2009
    After Cataloging Delay (and Some Questions), NYPL Puts Exposé of Museum on the Shelves
    So, did the New York Public Library (NYPL) face pressure not to purchase Michael Gross’s new b...
    More
  • » VIEW ALL BLOGS RSS

Photos

  • Design Institute 2007
    December 11, 2007 at Chicago's Harold Washington Library Center:Design Institute 2007
  • Learning Gardens
    New York's GreenBranches program links the library to the street.
  • Green Picks: LBD May 2007
    Want to reduce your library's carbon footprint? Join the Cradle-to-Cradle revolution. Helen Milling shares the green products her firm is using.
Advertisements





LJ NEWSLETTERS

Click on a title below to learn more.

LJ BookSmack
LJXPRESS
LJ ACADEMIC NEWSWIRE
LJ REVIEW ALERT
CRÍTICAS
©2009 Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
Use of this Web site is subject to its Terms of Use | Privacy Policy
Please visit these other Reed Business sites