Library Journal Mobile
Log In  |  Register          Free Newsletter Subscription
Subscribe to LJ Magazine

The End of LCSH? Provocative Report Stirs Up Cataloging Discussion

-- Library Journal, 4/24/2006

Should the Library of Congress (LC) jettison Library of Congress Subject Headings (LCSH), the longstanding professional taxonomy? That's one of the provocative suggestions in a new report announced Tuesday by the LC. But "The Changing Nature of the Catalog and Its Integration with Other Discovery Tools," commissioned by LC and written by Associate University Librarian Karen Calhoun of Cornell University, was already making waves weeks earlier, thanks to a critical review of a draft of her paper, written for AFSCME 2910, the Library of Congress Professional Guild, by Thomas Mann (author of The Oxford Guide to Library Research). The summary in LC's press release doesn't mention LCSH, but states that libraries should reduce the costs of producing catalogs; enrich the catalog with Amazon-like features like reviews and images; and offer rush delivery of materials and other services. Mann criticized the premises behind the report, warning of "serious negative consequences for the capacity of research libraries to promote scholarly research."

"Libraries are going to move at many different speeds," Calhoun said, noting that the members of the Association of Research Libraries for which the report is intended could participate in three potential strategies. The first, "Extend," would involve improved interfaces and simplification of cataloging for libraries maintaining a local catalog for a locally-housed and -circulated collection. For the second, "Expand," shared regional catalogs could serve more users. For the most ambitious strategy, "Leadership," she said, "There is no fully realized version anywhere. I think the Google Five [Stanford, Univ. of Michigan, Harvard, Oxford, and New York Public Library] have some elements of what it's going to take." An aggregated supply of library resources on search engines like Google could then support speedy delivery of materials in multiple formats, include digital and print-on-demand. LC Associate Librarian Deanna Marcum said, "Tom [Mann] quite rightly points to the superiority of doing searches the library way." However, she said, "Instead of trying to force the users into our systems, are there ways we can take our vast resources to where the users are?" She added, "I can't imagine a scenario in which we end LCSH completely. I think we will be trying to figure out what part of the work we do adds value and is meaningful to our user community."

Talkback

We would love your feedback!

Post a comment

» VIEW ALL TALKBACK THREADS

Related Content

Related Content

 

By This Author

There are no other articles written by this author.

Sponsored Links




 
Advertisement
Sponsored Links

MOST POPULAR PAGES

More Content

  • Blogs
  • Podcasts
  • Photos

Blogs

  • Liz Danforth
    Games, Gamers, & Gaming

    March 16, 2009
    Why Games?
    So here’s the core question: do games belong in libraries? Or perhaps you’ve heard it in...
    More
  • Cheryl LaGuardia
    E-Views

    September 25, 2008
    CQ Almanac and CQ Global Researcher: Try Them Here for Free!
    CQ Press has come through handsomely with 2 trials for blog readers: you can try out both the CQ Alm...
    More
  • » VIEW ALL BLOGS RSS

Photos

  • Design Institute 2007
    December 11, 2007 at Chicago's Harold Washington Library Center:Design Institute 2007
  • Learning Gardens
    New York's GreenBranches program links the library to the street.
  • Green Picks: LBD May 2007
    Want to reduce your library's carbon footprint? Join the Cradle-to-Cradle revolution. Helen Milling shares the green products her firm is using.
Advertisements





LJ NEWSLETTERS


Booksmack
LJXpress
LJ Academic Newswire
LJReview Alert
LJ Criticas Review Alert
SLJ Extra Helping
Curriculum Connections
SLJTeen
PWDaily
Children's Bookshelf
PW Comics Week
Cooking the Books
Religion BookLine
Please read our Privacy Policy
©2009 Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
Use of this Web site is subject to its Terms of Use | Privacy Policy
Please visit these other Reed Business sites