Another Casualty
By Margaret M. Jobe -- Library Journal, 5/15/2003
Last year the government documents community became alarmed by a growing trend on the part of the federal government to suppress access to information in the name of national security. The Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), U.S. Geological Survey (USGS), and other federal agencies removed information deemed "sensitive" from web sites and, in the case of the USGS, from depository libraries.
Many think the Bush administration seems intent on reducing access to information. The most recent casualty in that offensive is PubScience. In November 2001, after three short years, the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) pulled the plug on the database.
Origin of PubSciencePubScience, launched in 1999, was modeled on the highly successful National Library of Medicine's PubMed database (www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi). Its stated purpose was to "facilitate searching and accessing peer reviewed journal literature in the physical sciences and other energy-related disciplines." PubScience, with support from some scholarly societies and commercial publishers, provided citations and abstracts for over two million articles from hundreds of scholarly journals.
As with PubMed, PubScience linked directly from citations to their respective journals. Access to individual articles was dependent on subscriber status. The increased discovery of resources could lead to increased sales of scholarly research materials, a win-win situation for publishers and the research community. Not so according to lobbyists from the Software and Information Industry Association (SIIA), who argued that PubScience unfairly competed against private-sector databases such as Scirus (www.scirus.com) and Infotrieve (www.infotrieve.com). In SIIA's view, the federal government should provide resource and discovery tools for government information only, ignoring the reality that most basic research in the physical sciences is funded by the federal government.
Database danger ahead?Despite vigorous opposition from a broad-ranging coalition of library and government watchdog groups, SIIA arguments held sway. PubScience is no more. With this win under SIIA's belt, many fear the association will tackle other citation databases produced directly or indirectly by the federal government. AGRICOLA (www.nal.usda.gov/ag98) and Global Legal Information Network (www.loc.gov/law/glin) are rumored to be next.
To be fair, some critics feel that PubScience never lived up to its early promise. Nevertheless, while the database may never have equaled the sum of its parts, it only existed for three years and certainly could have improved with time. It is very troubling, however, that the DOE parroted arguments advanced by the SIIA in its justification to close the database.
The 2002 listThe Notable Documents List was established by the the American Library Association's Government Documents Round Table (GODORT) in 1984 to "foster awareness of foreign, international, state and local documents available in American libraries" and to "encourage nondepository libraries to acquire government publications." The resources included in this year's list cover a broad range of topics: science, current events, policy issues, and history.
Information is both the currency and lingua franca of commerce, development, continued scientific advancement, and citizen participation. The Government Documents Round Table and its members remain committed to access to government information. To find out more about GODORT and its work, visit the round table homepage (sunsite.berkeley.edu/GODORT). It features an extensive array of information, including news about policy developments and current issues of concern.
Many of these resources are available at federal depository libraries. Find those near you at the Locate Federal Libraries page (www.access.gpo.gov/sudocs/locators/findlibs/index.html).
FEDERAL DOCUMENTS
Aerospace Science: Frontiers of Aviation History. 2d ed. by DeShana E. Chisolm &
others. Maxwell Air Force Base, Air Force Reserve Officer Training Corps, U.S.
Air Force. 2002. 580p. illus. SuDoc # D 301.26/6:AE 8/2/2002.
Written to
provide junior ROTC members with basic knowledge about the origins and
continuing development of aerospace, this book would be useful for anyone with
an interest in military history. It is divided into four units—Heritage of
Flight, Development of Air Power, Toward Military Aerospace, and Contemporary Aviation—and is designed as an instructional text with "words to remember" and questions at the end of each chapter.
America's Children: Our Challenge, Our Future; U.S.A. Report on Progress Toward the Goals of the 1990 World Summit for Children. U.S. Department of Health & Human Svcs.
2001. 103p. illus. SuDoc # HE 1.2:C 43/9. NTIS # PB2002102691.
In 1990, the U.S. delegation to the World Summit on Children defined certain negative health conditions and risk factors that specifically affect American children and adolescents and articulated a set of ten-year goals in a report titled A Culture of Caring: America's Commitment to Children and Families. America's Children describes the
progress toward those goals and the remaining challenges we as a nation face. Conclusions are supported by a variety of data collected from federal agencies.
Building the Bombs: A History of the Nuclear Weapons Complex. by Charles R. Loeber. Sandia
National Laboratories, U.S. Department of Energy. 2002. 280p. illus. SuDoc # E
1.2:B 86/9. Stock # 061-000-00960-4. $29.
This history of the Nuclear Weapons
Complex (NWC), a group of government-owned but contractor-operated laboratories,
includes a general chronicle of the U.S. nuclear program. The book opens with a
description of early breakthroughs in atomic physics by Einstein and others and
continues with a study of the Manhattan Project during World War II. Written for
the layperson and covering developments in the Cold War and post–Cold War eras, the book also explains the basic principles of nuclear weaponry.
Empty Promises: The Myth of College Access in America; A Report.
Advisory Committee on Student Financial Assistance, U.S. Department of Education. 2002. 60p. illus. SuDoc # ED 1.2:P 94/11. NTIS # PB2002108565. www.ed.gov/offices/AC/ACSFA/emptypromises.pdf.
This report outlines the arguments for reauthorizing the Higher Education Act of 1965. It is divided into four main sections: Financial Barriers, Impact on Students, National Consequences, and Implications for Federal Policy. Illustrated with numerous bar graphs and charts, it follows up on the commission's 2001 report Access Denied: Restoring the Nation's Commitment to Equal Educational Opportunity.
Federal Justice in the Mid-Atlantic South: United States Courts from Maryland to the Carolinas, 1789– 1835. by
Peter Graham Fish. Administrative Office of the United States Courts. 2002.
352p. illus. bibliog. index. SuDoc # JU 10.2:C 83/6. OCLC # 49848022.
This thoroughly researched and footnoted history of the 4th Circuit Courts during the formative years of American jurisprudence encompasses the states of Maryland, Virginia, and North and South Carolina. Fish (political science and law, Duke Univ.) has reviewed and analyzed hundreds of federal statutes, presidential decisions, and court cases relevant to the development of the national court system and the role of the federal judiciary in building the new nation. The cases and events surrounding them are vividly described in nonlegalese. With an extensive bibliography and four indexes (court cases, names, statutes, and subjects), Federal Justice should find a home in all
public or academic libraries.
Menu Magic for Children.
U.S. Department of Agriculture. 2002. 35p. illus. SuDoc # A 98.8/ 2:328. www.fns.usda.gov/tn/Resources/menu_magic.pdf.
Intended for child-care providers, this slim volume contains recipes and
menu planners for various age groups. It also includes shopping guides and
explanations of the basic principles of nutrition. It would be a useful tool for
any kitchen where meals are prepared for children.
Our Vanishing Past: The Crisis of Cultural and Paleontological Resources on BLM Lands. Bureau
of Land Management. 2002. 138p. illus. maps. SuDoc # I 53.2: C89/6. NTIS #
PB2002103530.
This timely report contains state-by-state presentations of
cultural and paleontological resources available on Bureau of Land Management
(BLM)–managed public lands and describes current threats posed by individual
collectors, recreational activities, or nature itself. Via statistics and colored maps, the book documents the preservation efforts of BLM and its partners.
A Quiet Crisis in America: A Report to Congress.
Commission on Affordable Housing & Health Facility Needs for Seniors in the 21st Century. 2002. 492p. SuDoc # Y 3.2:H 81/3/C 86. Stock # 052-003-01492-1. $48. www.seniorscommission.gov/pages/final_report/finalreport.pdf.
By 2020, 20 percent of the U.S. population will be over the age of 65.
Additionally, recent changes in American lifestyles are creating barriers that
previous generations of the elderly did not face. The thesis of the commission's
report is that America needs to begin preparing now to meet the housing and
health needs of the growing elderly population because the private sector alone
is not equipped to do so. Congress needs to begin immediately putting
appropriate statutory and financial structures in place to address adequately
our "quiet crisis"—the current and future needs of an aging population.
Science.gov.
Office of Scientific & Technical Information, U.S. Department of Energy. 2002–. www.science.gov.
A collaborative effort of a number
of disparate agencies, including the departments of Agriculture, Commerce,
Defense, Education, Energy, Health and Human Services, and Interior;
Environmental Protection; NASA; and National Science Foundation, this portal
aims to provide one-stop shopping for scientific and technical information from
key federal sources. In addition to a browsable collection of links, the site
features a keyword search engine that covers the web sites of all participating
agencies as well as a classified collection of annotated links to indexes and
databases such as AGRICOLA, MEDLINE/PubMed, and NTIS, among others. This site
will be very useful for librarians with a limited personal acquaintance with
scientific and technical information.
Connecticut
A Fisheries Guide to Lakes and Ponds of Connecticut, Including the Connecticut River and Its Coves.
3d ed. by Robert P. Jacobs & Eileen B. O'Donnell. Connecticut Department of Environmental Protection. 2002. 354p. illus. maps. LC 2002025689. ISBN 0-942085-12-4. $29.95; pap. ISBN 0-942085-11-6. $19.95.
Over 20 years'
worth of sampling, monitoring, and data evaluation culminates in the third
edition of one of the state's most popular and enduring publications. Considered
a bible for sport fishers, this volume includes information on fish populations
and habitats, lake and pond ecology, lake productivity, water clarity, thermal
stratification, and aquatic vegetation. The work also features colorful
photographs
and bathymetric maps.
Maryland
Town Creek: Long-Range Planning Guide for Ecosystem Management.
Department of Natural Resources–Forest Service. 2002. 35p. illus. OCLC # 50916196. pap. Free.
This guide was developed with
information gathered from stakeholders. The work includes objectives and
recommendations for ecosystem management within the Town Creek watershed. The
volume, which includes case studies, summarizes program studies, restoration
projects, the views of community leaders, and lessons learned over
time.
New Jersey
New Jersey's Underground Railroad Heritage: "Steal Away, Steal Away…"; A Guide to the Underground Railroad in New Jersey.
New Jersey Historical Commission. 2002. 12p. illus. bibliog. OCLC # 49700365. pap.
Beginning with a brief introduction to the Underground Railroad, this work
also includes a chronology of significant events relating to the movement in New
Jersey. Brief biographies of key figures combine with photographs and
descriptions of important sites, e.g., churches and private homes. A
bibliography completes the work.
North Dakota
More Dakota Day Trips: "Discovering North Dakota's Hidden Treasures."
by Cliff Naylor & Monica Hannan. North Dakota Department of Commerce, Tourism Division. 2001. 120p. illus. OCLC #48505540. ISBN 0-9675758-1-8. pap. $9.95.
The cover illustration says it all: Naylor and Hannan are gassing up the car and heading out to discover the sights and sounds of rural North Dakota. Most of the stories are based on Naylor's KFYR-TV series Off the Beaten Path. The narratives
are accompanied by photographs of unique people, places, and haunts that may not
be found in the typical travel
guide.
Oklahoma
Annotated Bibliography of Government Documents Related to the Threat of Terrorism and the Attacks of September 11, 2001.
comp. by Kevin D. Motes. Oklahoma Department of Libraries. 2002. OCLC #49648864. www.odl.state.ok.us/usinfo/terrorism/911.htm. pap.
Downloaded over 73,000 times, this timely,
annotated bibliography provides access to information produced by the U.S.
government on the events of September 11, 2001. Items are arranged
alphabetically by document title within a broad range of subject areas. URLs to
individual documents are provided when applicable, and SuDoc numbers are given
to assist users in locating publications at depository libraries. Volume 2
updates information since April 2002. Motes is with the U.S. Government
Information Division, Oklahoma Department of Libraries.
Forty-Six Important Federal Publications About Oklahoma—the 46th State. by Steve Beleu. 2001.
Oklahoma Department of Libraries. 15p. OCLC # 47593533. Free while copies
last.
This bibliography lists 46 federal government publications that highlight important events in Oklahoma history, including The Five Civilized Tribes, Gold and Silver Fever, The Wichita National Forest, Rights of Women in Oklahoma, Remembering Will Rogers, The Dust Bowl, and Oklahoma City Bombing. Each entry
includes the title, author, a physical description of the publication, SuDoc number, and a brief annotation.
Tennessee
Building Tennessee's Tomorrow: Anticipating the State's Infrastructure Needs.
by Harry A. Green. Tennessee Advisory Commission on Intergovernmental Relations. 2002. 221p. www.state.tn.us/tacir/infrastructure.htm.
This
report is the third in a series on public infrastructure needs prepared by the
Tennessee Advisory Commission on Intergovernmental Relations (TACIR). The
primary charge of TACIR is to develop programs that would "improve the quality
of life of its citizens, support livable communities, and enhance and encourage
the overall economic development of the state."
Wisconsin
Teaching Character Education Using Children's Literature: Wisconsin's Standards of the Heart.
Wisconsin Department of Public Instruction; Division for Learning Support: Equity and Advocacy and Division for Learning Support: Instruction Services. 2001. 72p. ISBN 1-57337-099-1. pap.
or CD-ROM. $12; $18 out-of-state.
This timely and
well-organized publication is tailored for education professionals and parents.
Sample features include teaching learning strategies and extensive
bibliographies of literature for children and young adults. A "standard of the
heart" is defined as the development of productive, responsible, caring, and contributing citizens.
Transportation Planning Resource Guide: A Guide to Preparing the Transportation Element of a Local Comprehensive Plan. Wisconsin Department of Transportation, Division of Transportation Investment Management, Bureau of Planning. 2001. 88p. maps OCLC # 47139700. www.dot.wisconsin.gov/localgov/docs/planningguide.pdf.
Published in print and on the web, this guide was designed to assist local
government officials in developing the transportation element of a community's
comprehensive plan. Special features include appendixes with contact
information, maps, a resource directory, and a reference list.
Virginia
The Capitol of Virginia: A Landmark of American Architecture. by Fiske Kimball. rev. &
expanded ed. Library of Virginia. 2002. 95p. illus. LC 2002110170 ISBN
0-88490-203-X. $25.
This revised and expanded edition of Kimball's 1989 work
focuses on continuing research on Virginia's capitol. In a new introduction,
Charles Brownell (Virginia Commonwealth Univ.) brings together the research
published since 1990, some of which points to flaws in Kimball's original
conclusions. Architectural drawings accompany Brownell's text. An essay by
conservator F. Carey Howlett summarizes an eight-year project to conserve and
research an architectural model commissioned by Thomas Jefferson. An analysis
of the model offers fresh insights into the building's origins. An excellent source for research and general collections.
Africa Environment Outlook: Past, Present and Future Perspectives. UNEP. 2002. 410p. illus. ISBN
92-807-2101-1. Sales # 02.III.D.20. $37.50.
This in-depth discussion of
Africa's environmental issues begins with an overview of the period 1972–2002.
The book contains a detailed examination of current environmental issues and
their policy framework. The volume also considers human vulnerability to
environmental change, as well as potential environmental concerns and policy
responses. Color photographs,
tables, graphs, and a list of references enhance the text.
Beyond Violence: Conflict Resolution Process in Northern Ireland. by Mari Fitzduff. UN University
Pr. 2002. 256p. ISBN 92-808-1078-2. Sales # E.02.III.A.13. $21.95.
Fitzduff, a professor of conflict studies at the University of Ulster who has been personally affected by the conflict in Northern Ireland, established INCORE, a conflict resolution training project that focuses on local issues. The program was later expanded to provide courses on conflict resolution geared toward policymakers and practitioners. This publication traces some of the history and main points of the conflict, moving into training, programs, and lessons learned. Included are the complete text of the Belfast Agreement
, notes, and references.
China in the World Economy: The Domestic Policy Challenges. OECD. 2002. 816p. illus. bibliog. ISBN
92-64-19707-9. $120.
Divided into two main headings—Sector Studies and
Economy-Wide Issues—this publication examines China's economy in detail. Each
chapter includes notes and a bibliography and is illustrated with numerous
tables and graphs. There are four appendixes: two on China and the World Trade
Organization, a section on tertiary education,
and a summary of China's main economic indicators.
Ecotourism: Principles, Practices and Policies for Sustainability.
by Megan Epler Wood. UNEP. 2002. 61p. illus. ISBN 92-807-2064-3. Sales # 02.III.D.14. $15. www.uneptie.org/pc/tourism/library.
The World
Conservation Union defines ecotourism as "environmentally responsible travel and
visitation to relatively undisturbed natural areas." This publication, written
by the president of the International Ecotourism Society, expands on the
definition and discusses components of success. Case studies, charts, and
black-and-white photos are found throughout. A listing of resource documents and
organizations is included.
The Future of Money. OECD. 2002. 176p. ISBN 92-64-19672-2. $19.
The Organisation
for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) Forum for the Future was
convened to discuss the future of money and credit in light of recent advances
in technology. This volume includes papers presented at the
meeting held in Luxembourg, July 2001.
Journeys of Jeopardy: A Review of Research on Trafficking in Women and Children in Europe.
by Elizabeth Kelly. International Organization for Migration. (Migration Series, No. 11). 2002. 69p. ISSN 1607-338X. $16. www.iom.int/documents/publication/en/mrs%5F11%5F2002.pdf.
According to this study, although international trafficking in women and
children is growing, knowledge about the size and scope of the problem is
incomplete. The book aims to "summarize what we know today but also to organize
the material into key themes, critically assess the knowledge base, and identify
gaps and future challenges." References are included.
Profiting from Abuse: An Investigation into the Sexual Exploitation of Our Children.
UNICEF. 2001. 44p. ISBN 92-806-3733-9. Sales #E.01.XX.14. $7.95. www.unicef.org/pubsgen/profiting/profiting.pdf.
This brief report includes moving words from the victims of child sexual
exploitation and summarizes the known facts and figures. According to the
report, some victims are bought and sold as many as 12 times. Steps being taken
to counter this global horror are included.
Study on Women, Peace and Security. United Nations. 2002. 192p. bibliog. ISBN 92-1-130222-6.
Sales # E. 03.IV.1. $25.
Security Council Resolution 1325 (adopted October
2000) was the impetus for this study to determine "the impact of armed conflict
on women and girls, the role of women in peacebuilding, and the gender
dimensions of peace processes and conflict resolutions" (foreword). The
full-text
of the resolution as well as an extensive bibliography are also included.
Sustainable Sport Management: Running an Environmentally, Socially and Economically Responsible Organization. by David Chernushenko with Anna van der Kamp & David
Stubbs. UNEP. 2001. 245p. bibliog. ISBN 92-807-2072-4. Sales #E.01.III.D.46.
$35; CD-ROM $30.
Environmental issues cross over into the sports arena in
areas such as facilities operations, equipment and supply production, and
related services. The purpose of this publication is to provide ideas on how to
manage sport better in an environmentally sensitive manner. There are case
studies and a bibliography. Chernushenko is an individual member, the International Olympic Committee Sport and Environment Commission, and president, Green & Gold, Inc.
Understanding the Brain: Towards a New Learning Science. OECD. 2002. 114p. ISBN 92-64-19734-6.
$20.
This publication summarizes the work of a collaborative project between
brain and learning researchers and policymakers. It is divided into three parts:
Premises, Cognitive Neuroscience Meets Education, and Conclusion, which also
outlines next steps. References
and a glossary are also included.
United Nations Yearbook Collection 1946– 1999. 2 vols. United Nations. 2002. ISBN
92-1-100907-3. Sales #E.03.I.8. CD-ROM. $500/$150 renewal (single user);
$1000/$300 renewal (networked).
Available for either single users or networks, this two-CD-ROM set contains the complete full texts of all 53 annual United Nations Yearbooks—a key resource for research
on both the history of the United Nations and its role in world events.
Compatible with Windows, Macintosh, Linux, and UNIX operating systems, the
CD-ROMs
allow for
browsing by year or searching by index terms. Annual updates to the set are planned.
World Public Sector Report: Globalization and the State. UN Department of Economic & Social
Affairs. 2001. 184p. illus. ISBN 92-1-123145-0. Sales # E.01.II.H.2 $25.
A
first edition of a planned biennial report, this volume addresses the role of
the state in issues relating to globalization, such as poverty, human rights, environment, development, and international crime. It features tables, graphs, and a list of references.
| Chair | Margaret M. Jobe, University of Colorado at Boulder |
| Federal Selector | Mark Anderson, University of Northern Colorado, Greeley |
| Federal Judges | Charmaine Henriques, University of Northern Colorado, Greeley |
| Vicki L. Tate, University of South Alabama, Mobile | |
| State & Local Selector | Janet Justis, Old Dominion University, Norfolk, VA |
| State & Local Judges | Bill Richardson, Kentucky Dept. for Libraries & Archives, Frankfort |
| Susan Xue, University of Colorado at Boulder | |
| International Selector | Barbara Mann, Emory University, Atlanta |
| International Judges | Maxine Grosshans, University of Maryland School of Law, Baltimore |
| Margaret Renton, University of California–Irvine | |
| TO SUBMIT NOMINATIONS: Please include availability information and brief annotations with the online nomination form available at www.library.ucsb.edu/forms/godort-form.html. If possible, submit copies of state documents. Nominations for the next list should be submitted by December 31, 2003. | |
| Author Information |
| Margaret M. Jobe, Chair, Notable Documents Panel, American Library Association's Government Documents Round Table (GODORT), has worked at the University of Colorado at Boulder since 1995. She previously served as International Selector |
|


















